Feast of Our Lady of Sorrows: The Franciscan Connection

As the Church celebrates the Feast of Our Lady of Sorrows (September 15), it is good to know the important role that Franciscans played in promoting this particular image of Mary and why.

Cross of Christ central to Saints Francis and Clare

The Cross of Christ was central to Francis and Clare, as we know from the place the cross of San Damiano played in their lives and from Francis’s early prayer, “We adore you, Lord Jesus Christ, in all your churches throughout the whole world and we bless you, because by your holy cross you have redeemed the world.”

Crucifixion frescoe by Pietro Lorenzetti (c. 1315-1320) in the Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi

Promoting the suffering humanity of Jesus

But by the 1220s this emphasis took a new turn: in their preaching of penance, Franciscans promoted devotion to the suffering humanity of Jesus to draw people to conversion. It was important for Franciscans that people not simply should understand with their minds that Christ died on the cross for their sins, but that they convert their lives as a result. Therefore, Franciscan preachers wanted to touch peoples’ affections so that their hearts might be transformed and they would be motivated to abandon sin and choose the good.

Human mother’s compelling emotional effect

However, “no matter how much the humanity of Christ was emphasized, it was still difficult for the contrite spirit to relate its own human responses of love or suffering to the figure on the cross while conscious of Christ’s divinity. Some referent for computing the nature of God’s love for humanity was required . . . [and so drawing attention to] the love and compassion of a human mother for her suffering child would naturally have a compelling emotional effect in actuating the conversion of the affections and move the heart to repentance. . . “ (David Jeffrey, The Early English Lyric & Franciscan Spirituality).

Taking down the body of Jesus from the cross (frescoe by Pietro Lorenzetti in Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi)

Suffering figure of Mary moves people to repentance

So, from the time of Saint Anthony on, Franciscan preachers often focused on the suffering figure of Mary, standing in agony under the cross, to move Christians to repentance. This emphasis was certainly not unique to the Franciscans—a new penitential brotherhood, the Servants of Mary (Servites) in fact sprang up in Tuscany in the 1230s—but Franciscans were among the chief propagators of this trend.

Detail from frescoe by Pietro Lorenzetti in Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi that depicts the taking down of Jesus from the cross

Liturgical Sequence “Stabat Mater”

The famous sequence "Stabat Mater," used in the Church’s liturgy on this feast, is often attributed to the Franciscan Jacopone of Todi, but even before this, Saint Bonaventure wrote:

What tongue can tell,

what intellect grasp

the heavy weight of your desolation,